Before You Read

Warning: If you are Resistant to Logic, please stay away from this page. Because we will be Persistent with Logic to wear down your Resistance.

Friday, September 26, 2014

"Rs.1000 Coin to be in Circulation Soon in India ..."

Verdict :
Possible time of origin : October 2012
Circulation platforms : Facebook, Blog
Circulation geography : India
Original Message Version Under Analysis:

Analysis by Merofact Awareness Team: The Government of India has the sole right to mint all currency formats in India. The currency department of in Reserve Bank of India attends to the core statutory function of note and coin issue and currency management. This is a responsibility for Government of India according to the Coinage Act, 1906 which may get amended from time to time. Anyway the fact of our interest is that, coins can be issued up to the denomination of Rs.1000 as per the above mentioned Coinage Act, 1906. The designing and minting of coins in various denominations is also the responsibility of the Government of India. Coins are minted at the five India Government Mints at Mumbai (Maharashtra), Alipore (Kolkata), Saifabad (Hyderabad), Cherlapally (Hyderabad) and Noida (UttarPradesh). The coins are issued for circulation only through the Reserve Bank in terms of the RBI Act.

As early as October 1, 2012 The Hindu reported a article with headline " Rs.1,000 coin to be released ". If you bother to read beyond the headline, you'll see that they clearly mentioned "The coin is being brought out as a special product to commemorate 1,000 years of Brihadeeswara temple of Thanjavur." Brihadeeswara temple is one of the largest temples in India and one of India's most prized architectural sites. The temple is now a part of the UNESCO World Heritage Site known as the "Great Living Chola Temples". This temple is built by emperor Raja Raja Chola I and completed in 1010 AD, so it turned 1000 years old in 2010.

So there actually is a Rs. 1000 coin released by RBI to commemorate 1000 years of Brihadeeswara temple but not for circulation in the country. Copies of this coin will only be available with few collectors who responded in time. To know a first hand experience with this coin, you may like to talk to Mr. D Satya Buddu a famous Indian numismatist and a Facebook user. The Hindu interviewed him after he collected this coin.

Lets analyze the image provided above, what can be seen in the above image is that, the name of the country India and denomination 1000 are spelled out in Hindi and English also the coin bears the emblem of the Lion Pillar of Ashoka with the words ‘Satyameva Jayate’ in Hindi below it. But what is missing is that, on the reverse side there is a figure of Raja Raja Chola-1 in a standing posture with folded hands along with a figure of the Brihadeeswara temple and the words depicting the 1000 years of the temple written in Hindi and English and the place and the year 2010 can be seen. Each coin, weighs 35 gm with 80 per cent silver and 20 per cent copper.

Even though this Rs. 1000 coin exists in reality, but that is only for a few collectors, it is not in circulation for all in the country and neither meant to be so. That is why we gave this message a False verdict.

Thursday, September 25, 2014

"Nano Silver Effective Against Ebola ..."

Verdict :

Possible time of origin : August 2014

Circulation platforms : Web, Youtube, Email

Circulation geography : Global

Original Message Version Under Analysis:
Claimed at

Analysis by Merofact Awareness Team: Its just a mere claim by Dr. Rima Laibow voiced via NGO Natural Solutions Foundation and not a proven truth actually we do not know any nano silver preparation from any manufacturer that can cure a viral disease. The most of the propaganda about the effectiveness of nanosilver to cure viral diseases presents a well cited scientific report published in the Journal of Nanobiotechnolgy in 2005. The article presents data showing nanosilver particles of size 1-10 nm can interact with the surface of  HIV-1  and thereby inhibits their binding to susceptible human cells in vitro. Nine years passed by after this publication but we haven't heard of any clinical trial showing the effectiveness of nanosilver particles in curing HIV or any other viral diseases per se. 

US Food and Drug Administration seriously took note of the claims made by Natural Solutions Foundation and issued a warning notice to them day before yesterday (September 23. 2014). FDA 's letter addressed to Dr. Laibow went on to say "Based on FDA's review, we have determined that your websites promote these products ( Dr. Rima Recommends™ The Silver Solution also referred to as "Silver Sol Nano Silver™") for conditions that cause the products to be drugs under section 201(g)(1)(B)  of the Federal Food, Drug, and Cosmetic Act (the Act) [21 U.S.C. §321(g)(1)(B)]. The therapeutic claims on your websites establish that the products are drugs because they are intended for use in the cure, mitigation, treatment, or prevention of disease."
Nanosilver are nothing but suspension of silver as we know from jewelry in the form of too small particles ( diameter in the range of nanometer). The smaller size distribution of already known material may impart new properties to the material, which recently brought a lot of attention to nanscience & nanotechnology. The newly acquired properties of a nanomaterial as in nanosilver preparations can be beneficial but we can not rule out possibilities of negative effect on our health. So to deal with them specially to use them on humans, we should be extremely cautious. Some even suggests prolonged use of nanosilver can impact one's health rather negatively. 

Wednesday, September 24, 2014

MOM has Successfully Entered the Orbit of Mars

Verdict : 
Historic Event for India
Possible time of origin : 24.09.2014
Circulation platforms : All
Circulation geography : Global
Original Message Version (compiled) Under Analysis:
India created history on September 24, 2014 becoming the first country to successfully get a spacecraft into the Martian orbit on its first attempt. It is dubbed as Mars orbiter mission (MOM) or Mangalayaan. Before India, various countries have launched Mars missions, but out of the 51 attempts, only 21 were successful. ISRO (India) now joins the elite Mars orbiter club that comprises the NASA (USA), Soviet Union and the ESA (Europe). India's Mangalayaan is the cheapest Mars orbiter mission so far. It cost about a tenth of NASA's Mars mission Maven that entered the Martian orbit on September 22, 2014. Indian prime minister Mr. Narendra Modi applauded Indian scientists and had said, "Hollywood movie Gravity costs more than our space mission." The orbiter was launched on November 5, 2013 from Satish Dhawan Space Centre, Sriharikota, India and  after a 300 day flight, has covered a distance of 680 million km to reach the Red Planet's orbit. It'll go around Mars on an elliptical orbit with the closest point around 420 km and the farthest around 80,000 km. MOM will employ five equipment that collectively weight 15 kg to do scientific studies, most importantly it'll check for the presence of methane that can indicate just what kind of life existed on Mars, if at all.

Analysis by Merofact Awareness Team: 
As a matter of fact we are Indian and we got another reason to be proud of our country. Its a real pleasure to share this news to you. We congratulate ISRO team from the bottom of our heart. Whatever we compiled in the message above from various resources describes the magnitude of the real achievement from the scientists at ISRO. The spacecraft entered the Mars orbit at 07:18 IST  ( finalized by 07:42 IST ) on September 24, 2014. We strongly suggest all our readers to visit the ISRO's Mars Orbiter Mission page on Facebook and like. 

According to Wikipedia total cost of the Mars orbiter mission is around US $74 million out of which the satellite itself costs about US $25 million. On the other hand according to IMDB the movie Gravity had a budget of US $100 million. Mangalayaan have five scientific instrument payloads, namely; Lyman Alpha Photometer, Methane Sensor for Mars, Mars Exopheric Neutral Composition Analyzer, Mars Color Camera and Thermal Infrared Imaging Spectrometer. MOM was launched with PSLV ( Polar Satellite Launch Vehicle ) which is capable of launching 1600 kg satellites in 620 km sun-synchronous polar orbit and 1050 kg satellite in geo-synchronous transfer orbit. According to ISRO website so far PSLV has repeatedly proved its reliability and versatility by launching 70 satellites or spacecrafts, out of which 30 are Indian and 40 are foreign satellites, into a variety of orbits so far. 

All these put India, who deals in the satellite launching market under the name of Antrix Corporation Limited, into the forefront of the multi-billion dollar  global space market. As of the cost effectiveness, we want to share an intriguing calculation; the vehicle has traveled 680 million km for US $74 million, i.e. US $0.11 / km or Rs.6.6 / km, in our experience an average rikshaw puller charges more in India. 

Tuesday, September 23, 2014

A White Tiger has Killed an Student at Delhi Zoo

Verdict : 

Possible time of origin : 23.09.2014

Circulation platforms : All

Circulation geography : India

Original Message Version Under Analysis:
A youth was today mauled to death at Delhi Zoo by an adult white tiger when he accidentally fell into the enclosure while climbing its fence to take a picture. Though it is not clear how the youth, in his early 20s, fell into the enclosure, eyewitnesses said he had tried to climb the fence but slipped. The tiger did not attack the youth for a few minutes but became violent after someone threw a stone at it and guards started hitting the fence. Credit PTI
 Analysis by Merofact Awareness Team: 

India Today was one of the earliest news media sources to break the the shocking news over twitterThey also posted some unfabricated images and a video (caution: could be disturbing, we willfully avoided a link to the video) of the misshaping. Though there is little confusion about the identity and exact age of the unfortunate victim, we can safely assume that the young boy was in his twenties. International news media including BBC (english), CNN (english) and Spiegel  (deutsch / german) also responded quickly and started spreading the news worldwide.

Monday, September 22, 2014

File Extension Appearing to Viewer Can be Faked

Verdict :

Possible time of origin : September 2011
Circulation platforms : All
Circulation geography : Global

Original Threat Description (compiled) Under Analysis: 
Recently cyber criminals included in their arsenal a way to pass off malicious file as legitimate files by disguising Windows file extensions, and making them appear safe to download. Avast, the major digital security firm dubs this operation by malware operators as “Unitrix”. The “Unitrix” exploit takes several Unicode features designed for right-to-left languages and uses them to mask malicious executables as safe text, image, audio or video files. Combating Unitrix is difficult. The typical user looks only at the file extension, and allows a file to stay, or download a new file based primarily on the file extension. Unless the user is an expert with a thorough knowledge of the files that a system or application requires, the only way users can detect such malware-in-disguise is when the system displays additional details or the anti-virus or browser shoots up a warning message.
 Analysis by Merofact Awareness Team:   

Most avid internet users have been naturally trained not to launch untrusted *.exe files download from the Internet as they may be malicious. Though there are many other file extensions that can cause damage to your digital security, most users are not aware of them (Click here for a extensive yet incomplete list of executable file extensions). Most users have rather better knowledge about what types of files are safe (eg. *.doc, *.jpg, *.png, *.avi, *.mp3). Security concerned users apply a positive selection while choosing to download and open a file, i.e. they will allow the download to take place and will open the file only if the file extension shown are familiar and the user regard that as safe. 

But there’s one problem; by default Windows operating system hides file extensions in the file explorer. So the image.jpg present in your download folder file may actually be image.jpg.exe, and when you double-click it'll launch the potentially unwanted variety of *.exe file. So if you are a person who frequently downloads from internet, we expect you have checked the "Show file extensions" menu in your Windows settings, if not do that NOW. Once you were aware of the safe file extensions you could have opened them without any risk of security breach, but sadly only until around 2011. 

Net security scenarios have changed since Avast reported the Unitrix exploit. Simple yet factual description of the Unitrix exploit is under the head "Original threat ..." in this post. Hackers are using this new trick to cloak malicious files by disguising their file extensions to make them appear to user as safe to download and open i.e. run inside your computer with all the permissions available to the logged in user. A regular user just looks at the extension at the very end of the file name; for example, .doc for a Word document, and that is where the danger is, as .doc seen in user's file explorer window does not ensure that the file will open with default Word document viewer (usually MS Word) set in user's computer. Because Unitrix exploit can make the Windows operating system read the file name including the extension differently than what user sees on the screen. 

For a live example download a compressed file ( by clicking on this line then unzip the downloaded file in a preferable location in your computer. You should get a file named like egUnitrixGNP.doc with a supposed .doc extension. So if you double click on this file it should open with document viewer right? But it won't, if you try to open this file by double clicking you'll see the file is using the default *.png image viewer set in your computer to open the exactly same image you are seeing on this page above. 

Understandably if this example trick can work, it is also possible that any other seemingly safe file extension can be engineered to load a malicious infection in the users' computer. We found a simple way to check whether a suspected file is hiding its true file extension using Unitrix exploit. Just try to rename the file and it will tell Windows operating system to select the name and not the extension and magically you'll see a discontinuous selection, the part beyond the selection is having the real extension information, what will not fall in the safe category of file extensions. Other than this, the only other way a user may know something is a malicious executable file is if they scan the file with detecting security software. (You might say for the example provided, you can tell that is a image file from the associated icon. But that can be engineered too, we didn't indulged into that because that will take little more effort and might cross the line between an innocuous example and potentially unwanted.)

So start taking measures and restrict yourself to downloading files from trusted sources only. If you show interest in this post through comments we'll also write on whether a file with legitimate safe file extension can  carry potentially unwanted piece of code.

Sunday, September 21, 2014

"Modi's New project: Blood on call 104 ..."

Verdict : 

Possible time of origin : July 2014
Circulation platforms : Facebook, Whatsapp and even Blogspot
Circulation geography : India

Original Message Version Under Analysis: 
Modi's new project : "104 - Blood on Call" is the name of the new initiative which comes into being from this day onward and all one has to do in order to avail of this service is to call the aforementioned number 104 following which the much needed quantities of blood would be made available to you at your doorstep within four hours of receiving your call........
Bottles of certified and HIV free blood will initially be made available within a forty kilometer radius from the call centers set up at various locations throughout the length and breadth of the country and one would have to tender an amount of Rs. 450/- plus 100 Rs. as transportation costs (i.e Rs. 550/-) per bottle of blood ordered or received at your doorstep.......
According to PMO sources, this project will only be launched in select areas to begin with in the nature of a "pilot project" and it's footprint will gradually be increased to include every nook and cranny of our glorious motherland depending on the success of the pilot project.........
Further information about the same is awaited and shall be shared as soon as any such information is forthcoming but one should certainly doff one's hat to the Modi government in this case and hope and pray that this welcome initiative also does not go the way of similar initiatives that bit the dust for a multitude of reasons over varying periods of time........ 
Plz forward this message for people who don't read newspaper.. Many lives can be saved by this facility ........ plz circulate in ur groups. 

Analysis by Merofact Awareness Team: 
Even if some concepts are wrong and imaginary usually they do not originate completely de novo, rather they build upon some existing fact or idea. This message is one such example, where the truths got distorted. The message reports about a pan India "blood on call service" project initiated by present Indian prime minister Mr. Narendra Modi. If you notice the message claims the project "comes into being from this day onward". Though you may receive the message today or have already received anytime after the message started spreading around the end of July 2014. This (missing a date stamp) is a fatal mistake for a news, and a common signature for many of the socially engineered merofacts.

There indeed is a "blood on call 104" service also known as "Jeevan Amrut Seva" scheme that have been started in the state of Maharashtra, but not pan India. See the following Youtube video clip reporting initiation of Jeevan Amrut Seva scheme (audio language marathi). 
Jeevan Amrut Seva scheme shares similar features as said in the message but only available in the state of Maharashtra from January 7, 2014 as launched by public health department of Maharashtra government. Click here to see the reporting of Daily News and Analysis on the inauguration of Jeevan Amrut Seva scheme. 

On the eve of World blood donor day (a WHO campaign) on June 14, 2014 honorable PM Mr. Narendra Modi raised awareness about the importance of blood donation and encouraged young to take a lead in that via Twitter posts

Take a note of the time line here; January 7, 2014 Jeevan Amrut Seva scheme inaugurated in Maharashtra, May 26, 2014 Mr. Narendra Modi assumed PM office in Delhi, June 14, 2014 PM Mr. Narendra Modi tweeted to encourage blood donation. In our opinion, some tricky mind must have taken the three above mentioned facts as seed and crafted a socially engineered message with little if any intention to cause harm. 
Till now there is no official news about pan India "blood on call service" scheme. Such a service would be really nice to avail, but till we get there we have to depend on classical approach. So if you are not in Maharashtra don't sit relaxed with the thought that you can get perfectly good packet of blood at your doorstep when you need. Rather it is always good to stock few telephone numbers and addresses of local blood banks in your area. We would suggest you to try calling 104 and share your experience with all of us in the comments section. 

Saturday, September 20, 2014

"Ebola Virus Reached Apollo Hospital (India)..."

Verdict : 
Possible time of origin : August 2014
Circulation platforms : Whatsapp (primary), also being shared on Facebook 
Circulation geography : India

Original Message Version Under Analysis: 
Ebola virus reached Apollo Hospital, Delhi Metro Hospital, faridabad and few cases found in Bansal Hospital, NFC. So kindly avoid to visit these Hospital for any kind of infection unfortunately!! Infected patient Sreejith-M.Tech, NIT suratkal, expired today. Please take precautions against Ebola virus and spread the awareness!!
Friends plz eat tulsi leaves to safeguard yourself from this virus Ebola becz Ebola virus directly effects the human immune system. Tulsi leaves are good for the human immune system so this is a precaution to save u from the Ebola virus... Use hot water and salt to take your bath in the morning, do the same when you want to drink water (hot and salt). ...  It is said to be a traditional vaccine for Ebola. 
Please don't keep this information to yourself send to all your contacts including your enemies. God bless you as you share this.
Analysis by Merofact Awareness Team: 

Image Description : Scanning electron micrograph with artificially imparted color on Ebola virus budding from the surface of a Vero cell (African green monkey kidney epithelial cell line). Credit: NIAID, USA
According to World Health Organization, the total number of probable, confirmed and suspected cases in the current outbreak of Ebola virus disease in West Africa was 5335 , with 2622 deaths (between the start of 30 December 2013 i.e. start of epidemiological week 1 and end at 14 September 2014 epidemiological week 37). Countries affected are Guinea, Liberia, Nigeria, Senegal and Sierra Leone. 

What we found from the published news and and reports available over the web, clearly suggests that Ebola virus have not crossed the Indian shoreline yet (we'll update if we encounter any factual report). On August 9, 2014 The Hindu quoted Union Minister for Health Dr. Harsh Vardhan who clarified that India does not have any confirmed or even suspected Ebola virus affected person. A control room with Ebola helpline numbers 23063205, 23061469 and 23061302 was supposedly operational from the same day morning at the Health Ministry. When we tried to contact these numbers, some of them worked (please use 011, STD code for Delhi) and confirmed that yet there is no official reported case of Ebola infection inside India.

For about last one and half month, the message above started roaming the social media. The Times of India took attention on this Ebola scare spreading over social media in India on September 12, 2014 and dismissed the message by quoting Dr. Anupal Sibal, medical director at Apollo Hospital who denied having received any Ebola case.

So far we couldn't find any published document on the effect of Tulsi and warm water with salt against anything related to Ebola and the disease it cause. In the mean time, a report appeared on September 18, 2014 in The Times of India, suggesting certain unidentified  people claim to have knowledge of ayurveda that can cure Ebola. TOI also quoted Karnataka health minister UT Khader, saying "I was approached by some people about ayurveda having a cure for Ebola. I was more interested in a cure for malaria and dengue." The comment summarizes the present need in India. Malaria and Dengue is causing havoc in Indian subcontinent and people with proper knowledge of Ayurveda should find answer to those before indulging themselves into finding cure of remotely threatening Ebola.
Lastly, we want to share an important news for the patrons who took part in spreading the Ebola rumor message and still thinking of doing so. On August 19, 2014 Indian Express quoted concerned Karnataka health minister UT Khader saying "This is not the first time that online platforms have been used to create fear, unrest and unnecessary apprehension among the public. We have decided to investigate and take action against persons spreading such false rumors.” So, you should look up for the facts before you believe anything, that you find in social media. Not only that you should be really cautious before you decide to share the same message over social media literally owning them (i.e. taking responsibility). Any negligence on this front can really put you into big trouble out of the blue.

If you encounter any such messages please comment below or drop a mail to us by clicking on the "message in a bottle" image (Report a circulating merofact) on the right side panel of this page. We'll respond as soon as possible with an analysis on this blog. 

Friday, September 19, 2014

General Format of a MeroFact Analysis Post

Verdict : 
Possible time of origin : Month YYYY ( if known )
Circulation platforms : Email / Facebook / Twitter / Whatsapp / Hike / Advertisements
Circulation geography : Africa / Asia / Australia / Europe / North america / South america / Global

Original Message Version Under Analysis: (Disclaimer from Merofact Team for all Subsequent Posts: We may take some liberty to modify the version of the message we receive for better readability. Specifically we might but not necessarily rectify the spelling mistakes and the use of punctuation and emoticons, overall the content will remain the same as to its meaning and intention)
blah ... blah ...
Analysis by Merofact Awareness Team:
Note: As we mentioned in the earlier post, whenever possible we will provide link to the original knowledge resources we used in our analysis. To read the original knowledge resources provided this way, you can just hover on the part of the text inside the posts and click on the highlighted area to reach the relevant web resource. Please add your comment below if you have any suggestion/s regarding the organization and topic coverage of the merofact analysis post. You can also send a personal message if you want, just click the "message in a bottle" image on the right side panel of this page.

Thursday, September 18, 2014

Why to Start MeroFact Awareness Blog

Social networking services (referred to more broadly as social media) connect a user with his/her peers globally while sharing their wider interests. Social media are not just bringing the users into personal online conversations, they are also helping people to follow news, breaking news, advise, advertise, contribute to online debates or even learn from others. Social media messages are a form of communication used to encourage or persuade an audience to continue sharing or take some new action. The communications can be made either through internet based social media portals (eg. Facebook ) or cross platform instant messaging services (eg. Whatsapp, Hike). 

Influence of social media is growing so fast and so powerful that some experts suggest that social media will become the new search function for the users and will result in people spending less time navigating the original resources independently and analyzing them rather they would search for information or even make decisions based on “word of mouth” recommendations from their social media peers. This poses a challenge to establish effective rules for social networking services where everybody participates but nobody owns, but rules are necessary to maximize freedom with minimal risks in navigation. It is so common among the people that they hardly realize that freedom comes with certain responsibilities. As it comes for free people tend to misuse the freedom without having a thought about the collateral damage it can cause to others. The relative freedom enjoyed so far by social networking services has caused concern regarding the potential of its misuse by individual users.
At any point of time, there is likely to be many thousands of completely bogus, untruthful and even damaging messages (which I like to call merofact) propagating like a pyramid scheme via legitimate vehicle like sharing through wall posts, emails and instant messages. Some of them are newly created and others have been circulating in various forms for years. Many people ask the interesting question, “Why they originate at all”. Such messages are having so much variation in target audience, topic and intentions that there cannot be single definitive answer. We can broadly categorize all the merofacts into three groups based on interpreted intentions; Hoax, Advertisement and Scam. 

The motives of a scam are not hard to determine. Usually a widespread scam rewards the scammer in the form of stolen funds or stolen identities and distribution of an advertisement brings in legitimate benefit in either form to an advertiser whereas hoax creator hardly enjoys a tangible benefit from the viral spread of the hoax. Given the rather mystifying complexity of human cognition, there is likely to be quite a number of causes why people create hoaxes.
Merofact awareness blog will fight the spread of all those merofacts across platforms by growing awareness among larger audience. We will try our best to analyze and refute any merofacts we come across.  We need input from all our readers and friends in this area, please use the "message in a bottle" image on the right side panel on this page to report a circulating merofact to us. We also would like to have some comments from our readers and friends on our analysis and their presentation. Whenever possible we will provide link to the original knowledge resources we used in our analysis.